Keyless entry vs. traditional locks: Which is right for you?

Security is one of the most important aspects of any property, whether residential or commercial. Choosing the right type of lock plays a crucial role in keeping your home or business secure.

While traditional locks have been a staple for centuries, keyless entry systems are rapidly growing in popularity due to their convenience and advanced security features. But which one is right for you?

In this guide, we’ll compare smart locks and conventional lock-and-key systems, discussing their pros and cons to help you make an informed decision. At SMR Locksmiths Ltd, we install and service both types of locks, ensuring that you get the best security solution tailored to your needs.

Traditional Locks: Reliable and Time-Tested

Traditional locks have been the standard in security for centuries. Whether it’s a simple Yale lock or a high-security British Standard mortice lock, these mechanisms are widely used in homes, offices, and businesses across the UK. Despite advancements in security technology, traditional locks remain a strong and viable option for many property owners.

Advantages of Traditional Locks

1. Proven Reliability
   Traditional locks have stood the test of time. They have been used for centuries and have evolved to provide increasingly strong and secure mechanisms. High-quality locks, when properly maintained, can last for decades, making them a long-term investment for property security.
2. No Power or Connectivity Issues
   Unlike smart locks, traditional locks do not rely on electricity, batteries, Wi-Fi, or Bluetooth to function. This means you never have to worry about connectivity failures, power outages, or system malfunctions that could compromise security.
3. Lower Cost
   Conventional locks are generally more affordable than keyless entry systems, both in terms of initial cost and long-term maintenance. The cost of replacement keys or a locksmith service is often significantly lower than repairing or replacing a smart lock system.
4. Easy to Repair and Replace
   If a traditional lock gets damaged or needs replacement, it is usually a straightforward process. Locksmiths, including SMR Locksmiths Ltd, can easily repair or replace traditional locks without the need for complex diagnostics or software updates.
5. Fewer Cybersecurity Risks
   Unlike smart locks, traditional locks do not face the threat of hacking. Cybersecurity threats are non-existent, as there is no digital component that can be exploited by cybercriminals.
6. Wide Availability
   Traditional locks and their components are widely available at most hardware stores. Finding a replacement key or lock cylinder is easy and does not require ordering specialized components or software updates.
7. Durability in All Weather Conditions
   Unlike some electronic locks, traditional locks are not affected by extreme temperatures, rain, or humidity. They function reliably in all weather conditions, making them a preferred choice for external doors and gates.

Disadvantages of Traditional Locks

1. Lost or Stolen Keys
   Losing your keys can be a significant inconvenience and a potential security risk. If your keys fall into the wrong hands, an unauthorised person could gain access to your property.
2. Lockouts
   Forgetting your keys inside or losing them entirely can leave you locked out, requiring professional locksmith assistance to regain entry.
3. Limited Access Control
   With a traditional lock, you cannot easily control who has access to your property. Unlike smart locks, which allow temporary or restricted access codes, traditional locks require physical key handover for access.
4. No Remote Operation
   Traditional locks require you to be physically present to lock or unlock doors, whereas smart locks allow remote operation through a mobile app or access codes.
5. Key Duplication Risks
   Physical keys can be copied without the owner’s knowledge, potentially compromising security. Even high-security keys can sometimes be duplicated by skilled individuals.

Keyless Entry Systems: The Future of Security

Keyless entry systems, commonly known as smart locks, use electronic means to lock and unlock doors. These can be operated via PIN codes, mobile apps, biometrics, or even voice commands. Smart locks offer enhanced security and convenience, making them an increasingly popular choice for homeowners and businesses.

Advantages of Keyless Entry

1. Convenience
   Smart locks eliminate the need for carrying keys, reducing the chances of losing them. With a keyless entry system, access can be granted via a smartphone, PIN code, or fingerprint scan, making it easier for multiple users to enter without a physical key.
2. Remote Access
   Many smart locks allow you to lock and unlock your doors remotely using a smartphone app. This is especially useful for homeowners who want to let guests or service personnel inside while they are away.
3. Customisable Access
   Smart locks provide the ability to set temporary or permanent access codes for different users. You can grant a one-time entry code for visitors or schedule access permissions for employees or family members.
4. Enhanced Security Features
   Smart locks often include tamper alerts, auto-lock functions, and integration with security systems. Some models even feature biometric authentication, making them more secure than traditional locks.
5. Activity Tracking
   Many smart locks keep logs of entry and exit activity, allowing you to monitor who has accessed your property. This feature is especially beneficial for businesses and rental properties.
6. Integration with Smart Homes
   Smart locks can be connected to home automation systems, allowing seamless control alongside lighting, alarms, and surveillance cameras.
7. Eliminates the Need for Rekeying
   If a traditional key is lost or stolen, the lock often needs to be rekeyed or replaced. With a smart lock, access codes can be changed instantly without the need for physical alterations.

Disadvantages of Keyless Entry

1. Power Dependency
   Smart locks rely on batteries or a power source. If the battery dies and you don’t have a backup key, you could be locked out. Regular maintenance is required to ensure the system remains operational.
2. Cybersecurity Risks
   Since smart locks operate through digital networks, they are vulnerable to hacking. Strong passwords, firmware updates, and encrypted connections are essential to mitigate security risks.
3. Higher Initial Cost
   Smart locks generally cost more than traditional locks, both in terms of purchase price and professional installation.
4. Compatibility Issues
   Some smart locks require specific door types, additional hardware, or integration with existing smart home systems. Compatibility must be checked before purchase and installation.
5. Learning Curve
   Smart locks can be more complex to use than traditional locks. Users unfamiliar with digital technology may find it difficult to set up and manage access codes or smartphone apps.
6. Battery Replacement Needed
   Many smart locks operate on batteries, requiring periodic replacement. Forgetting to replace them can result in being locked out unexpectedly.

Which Lock is Best for You?

Choosing between a traditional lock and a keyless entry system depends on your specific needs. Here’s a breakdown of which might be better suited to different situations:

• For Homeowners Seeking Simplicity: Traditional locks provide a reliable, low-maintenance security solution.
• For Tech-Savvy Homeowners: Keyless entry system offers advanced features and remote access control.
• For Businesses: Smart locks allow enhanced access control and activity tracking.
• For Frequent Travellers: Remote control features in smart locks provide peace of mind while away.

SMR Locksmiths Ltd: Your Trusted Lock Installation Experts

At SMR Locksmiths Ltd, we provide professional installation services for both traditional locks and keyless entry systems. Whether you need a high-security mortice lock or a cutting-edge smart lock, our team can help you choose the best security solution for your property.

No matter which option you choose, SMR Locksmiths Ltd is here to help with expert advice, high-quality products, and professional installation. Contact us today to upgrade your security with confidence.